Having seen Project Hail Mary

I watched Project Hail Mary recently, and it reminded me how much the science matters in certain kinds of science fiction. The film is enjoyable, but a lot of the sharp, science‑driven detail that made the book so strong didn’t make it to the screen. I found myself wondering how well the story lands for anyone who hasn’t read the novel — the Beatles, the nitrogen problem, du Bois, zenonite, Taumeba… all the things that made Andy Weir’s work feel so clear and so clever.

Seeing the adaptation made me appreciate the book even more. Neil deGrasse Tyson once said something along the lines of: real science makes fiction more fun — and that’s exactly how I felt watching it.

And yet, I’ve always loved the softer side of sci‑fi too. Star Wars and Star Trek were part of my childhood: big universes, big ideas, big emotions. They’re not about physics; they’re about wonder. They’re brilliant in their own way.

But I’m not a Weir‑style writer. I’m not building engineering puzzles. My work sits closer to The Expanse — stories where the physics matters, the world behaves properly, and the consequences feel real, but the plot is driven by people, pressure, and the systems they’re caught inside. The science supports the story rather than being the story.

Watching Project Hail Mary reminded me how much I enjoy that balance. When the science is missing, some of the weight goes with it.

I explained a few of the gaps to my wife, and we still enjoyed the film, but if you love sci‑fi, I’d strongly recommend reading the novel. It’s one of those stories where the science is half the adventure.

From The Martian to Project Hail Mary

Back in September 2022, I wrote about Andy Weir after hearing him speak during ProWritingAid’s Writer’s Week. His interview stood out to me not just because The Martian is one of my all-time favourite stories, but because of how down-to-earth he came across. Despite his book ‘rocketing’ to success, Andy spoke with humour and humility, sharing how social media helped propel his work before a major publisher picked it up.
I was struck by his approach to research, which mirrors my own: keep the story internally consistent, even if the science bends a little. As he explained, the ferocious Martian storm that stranded Mark Watney couldn’t happen in reality, but it made for a brilliant opening. As Slartibartfast would say, “I’d rather be happy than be right any day.”
At the time, Andy admitted his follow-up novel Artemis hadn’t resonated with readers in the same way, partly because the protagonist wasn’t wholly likeable. I hadn’t read it myself, but I understood his point—sometimes a character can push us away before the story has a chance to pull us in.

Fast forward to now, and I’ve finally read Project Hail Mary. It was brilliant. The format and feel reminded me of The Martian—that same mix of humour, tension, and science-driven storytelling—but with its own fresh spark. I couldn’t help imagining Tom Hanks in the lead role, a cross between his Cast Away survivor and Matt Damon’s stranded botanist in The Martian. No offence to Ryan Gosling, who’s set to star in the film adaptation, but Hanks feels like such a natural fit for the lone astronaut.
What makes Project Hail Mary so good is exactly what Andy talked about back in 2022: believable science wrapped in compelling storytelling, with a protagonist readers can root for. It feels like a return to the hit writing that made The Martian such a success.
Looking back, I’m glad I put this book on my reading list. Andy Weir has proven once again that when you combine technical curiosity with a spark of imagination, you can create a story that captures readers and keeps them turning the pages.

Well, that went well…

Ludwig 2024

Next month

I will concentrate on Draft 2 of Annika Dash and The Dark Side of The Moon from now until the end of November. After that, I will let you know how I did. In the meantime, I will keep posting on my FaceBook page.